So Broken it is Actually Funny

Bylo Band

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

Banjo1012

Perhaps they decided because of his telepathy he became a faith healer later in life

Captain Q

Um... A doc with no bedside manners?

WhatMeWorry

He is probably upset - and therefore undiplomatic - about the new Medicare reimbursement rates for Doctors

*Nomad* {PoF}

But it isn't broken. We have page after page of data from players with charts and graphs and tables that prove it works just fine....... Just like those 65% v 5% that you always seem to lose, its not broken at all

*Nomad* {PoF}

Banjo1012 wrote: »

Perhaps they decided because of his telepathy he became a faith healer later in life

Acting Doctor Surak....or a Vulcan EMH maybe

Bylo Band

Nomad (FADM:Patterns of Force) wrote: »

But it isn't broken. We have page after page of data from players with charts and graphs and tables that prove it works just fine....... Just like those 65% v 5% that you always seem to lose, its not broken at all

If it is not broken, I would love an explanation as to how either Surak here has the Medicine skill, and after that I'd like an explanation as to how one Surak can have Diplomacy while the other does not, when both of them should.

WhatMeWorry

I think the official explanation is that it's a "boo boo"

MirrorVerse Jc

I hate surak in the gauntlet. Never paid attention to the crits and hits you are showing here. I just sacrifice someone who is tired bcuz i know i will loose everytime. Even against my own surak. Maybe this is why he always wins. He cheats. We need to have his blood factors checked to see if he is a romulan imposter or a changeling.

Vesmer

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

I’ve got one for you - “across all the universe of players it’s normal to assume that sometimes one Surak loses his DIP but gets MED for a minute, and other Surak gets MED but doesn’t lose his DIP, so it’s pretty normal. You know, you still can be killed by a shark in Montana, it’s not 0% chance”

*Nomad* {PoF}

Vesmer wrote: »

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

I’ve got one for you - “across all the universe of players it’s normal to assume that sometimes one Surak loses his DIP but gets MED for a minute, and other Surak gets MED but doesn’t lose his DIP, so it’s pretty normal. You know, you still can be killed by a shark in Montana, it’s not 0% chance”

PenguinJim

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

It's probably this issue, also reported here, here and here. Or maybe there are two different causes that produce this same effect. Shan, any update since this was reported last year?

Shan

I bring it up regularly, and it is on our radar but no update yet.

Bylo Band

PenguinJim wrote: »

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

It's probably this issue, also reported here, here and here. Or maybe there are two different causes that produce this same effect. Shan, any update since this was reported last year?

I am aware of those threads, but felt I should post this because I had never seen a thread reporting an error whereby a character received a skill (in this case Medicine) that they should not have.

PenguinJim

ByloBand wrote: »

PenguinJim wrote: »

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

It's probably this issue, also reported here, here and here. Or maybe there are two different causes that produce this same effect. Shan, any update since this was reported last year?

I am aware of those threads, but felt I should post this because I had never seen a thread reporting an error whereby a character received a skill (in this case Medicine) that they should not have.

Sure, but Caretaker got Com and Kahless got Sci in those threads.

Shan wrote: »

I bring it up regularly, and it is on our radar but no update yet.

Thanks.

Raijinmeister

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

"Working as intended"?

Average Guy

Raijinmeister wrote: »

ByloBand wrote: »

Would LOVE an explanation on this!

"Working as intended"?

As intended is not the same as correct. They are within their rights to run RNG as they intend, we have the right not to like it. 🤗

Prime Lorca

I got a similar, but different bug.



It looks like the rolls (roles?) were reversed.

Edit: For the two players who joined yesterday and do not have Mirror Jean Luc Picard, he has no MED skill.