Worst Super Rare Crew
![[SSR] GTMET](https://us.v-cdn.net/6030345/uploads/userpics/724/nA97JZAFVHVNR.jpg)
[SSR] GTMET
✭✭✭✭✭
in The Bridge
So, how does one define the worst super rare crew, is it total core skill, voyage value, how do you compare 2 vs 3 skill crew? Of my roster, I looked at the absolute weakest crew and ranked them relative to each other (2 skills vs each other, 3 skills vs each other) and tried to create a relative ranking. Here is what I came up with as the bottom worst of the worst. What do you think, should someone else make this list instead? Should It just be a list of the 1 and 2 skill crew at the bottom?
0
Comments
Yikes, I didn't realize he was that bad. Was he supposed to be a Rare card originally and then they bumped him up to purple but also didn't change anything?
On the flip side regarding worf and ezri, there are sooooo many Dax's and Worf's that I don't even unfreeze them in events because they don't make shuttles
When I looked at him in the past, I thought he could make it to gauntlet.
But, as far as the OP question whether only two or one stat. I have to agree there are 3 stat crew that do deserve to make the bottom 10. ( off the top of my head I would say all mirror crew could make for a bottom set)
Edit: Looking at list it looks like the mirror crew who are bad are two stats.
Edit2: 3 stats Weyoun Clone 4 is usually in my freezer. My second account less room, Fencing Sulu, Chief O'Brien, Command Hologram, Lieutenant Arex Na Eth, Agent Harris, Lore.
Also I believe both accounts have three Stats mentioned by OP in cryo.
(Except my main I have KDF Gowron, I will have to remember that when I need a slot)
Also, Mirror Jadzia and Mirror LaForge are actually pretty decent, Sato was at release too. All mirror is kinda harsh.
Mirror La Forge has not seen my freezer same with Dax. Also add Mirtor Phlox. I keep him around for gauntlets and voyages.
I think you were right about Sato. I do believe way back when she was my top DIP.
Looking at the mirror superrare, there was the mirror mega where going into it the only one I did not have cryoed in both my accounts was Phlox.
Now there are a few who would be hard to freeze one we did not mention was Mayweather another Leeta. But if you need room, might be forced to put La Forge and Leeta in.
Putting La Forge in reminds me of when I had to put Augment Riker and GI Chakotay in cryo. They both had been making it into gauntlets but at that time that was it. So I needed room and froze them both. Now with voyages, might be harder to Freeze Mirror La Forge, but it really comes down what you have as crew. For me right now, if I needed room I could see myself still holding Phlox but freezing La Forge.
Go ahead and nominate a 4* who is similar, but everyone approaches arena different and is looking for certain type of crew.
My nominee would probably be Rogue Harry Kim.
I gotta guess he does not have Kurn. Otherwise, he would be on his list.
Kurn was added in the last portal update, and I've had him drop a couple times. By the time they finally added him he was outclassed by almost every other com/sec klingon.
https://forum.disruptorbeam.com/stt/discussion/10524/a-wild-theory-i-have-regarding-the-behold-issue#latest
It took a while for me to get him after portal update too.
Edit: I am now starting to think you should have two lists one for two and one stat, and the other 3 stat.
Any crew with com/sec or dip/sec/com are extremely common in the game. Therefore, people with relatively rare stat combinations like Augment Riker may be more useful than he first appears, being in two collections, having a fairly unique stat combo, and being main crew, whereas Empress Sato is in no collections, and is in the same skill gang as Dancing Chekov, Romulan Picard, Dancing Sulu and Chancellor Gowron. Duchamps, Klingon Quark and Romulan Kirk all have the same skillset but a higher voyage rating. Only Luther Sloan in that group is worse than Empress Sato.
Check out our website to find out more:
https://wiki.tenforwardloungers.com/
Captain of the voyage vessels: Queen of Bashir, Landsknecht, and Sunspear, the first luxury starship cruiseliners.
Amenities include wifi, fully-functioning holodecks, a full-service bar, 3 party decks, a Trill spa, and a business centre.
Fun fact: The ships are propelled by bouncy castle technology.
I've found that adding a rank to each stat in my spreadsheet is a good way to help with my decision making. I may freeze a Cmd/Sec crew who is better than a particular Eng/??? crew, simply because of how low they rank on my skill (single skill or combo) depth chart.
Well, Ezri makes the cut mostly because Dax's tend to be more diverse in their primary skills. Most Worf's are pretty similar to each other but I think its enough to keep him out of the basement at least. Defiant Worf is also a decent Gauntlet crew.
And boy, are there a lot!
Commander Kelby (283)
Holonovel Doctor (293)
1701 Jadzia Dax (299)
The Clown (303)
Victorian Pulaski (306)
RAF Julian Bashir (308)
Commander Barak (315)
Resistance Shakaar (325)
Reinforcements Stamets (330)
Trader Odo (341)
The bottom 10 may seem like a "normal" cutoff. However, I wasn't looking for the bottom 10. Those are all of the 4*s with a total proficiency that is actually lower than the WORST 1* Character (Maquis Chakotay at 348).
I agree completely -- best and worst varies by skill. For security, thanks to Kortar, Mirror Picard, Mirror Jadzia, Robin Hood, etc., who were all winnable in events, if you don't have nearly 1k base skill in security, you're going into my freezer. With engineering, the bar is set considerably lower. But Ru'Afo will help change that.
Captain Level: 95
VIP Level: 12
Unique Crew Immortalized: 525
Collections Completed: Vulcan, Ferengi, Borg, Romulan, Cardassian, Uncommon, Rare, Veteran, Common, Engineered, Physician, Innovator, Inspiring, Diplomat, Jury Rigger, Gauntlet Legends
Agreed. I nearly froze First Goran’Agar because his base 922 (w/bonuses) COM score was just not quite enough to be worth keeping after I finally immortalized Commander Barak. (Thankfully, I kept him around because he has an extra skill Barak doesn’t and ended up saving some merits.) On the flip side, I still get regular use out of Professor Scott’s 858 base ENG and I tolerate Sybok’s 910 base diplomacy because Mintakan Troi is my only other top-15 diplomat with SCI.
Worst Gauntlet != Worst Crew
A lot of these crew are some of the best 4* for shuttles. I'm ok with crew who are very good for shuttles not having great gauntlet stats. People don't need to be the best at everything.
If I had to order them, probably in that order though it depends how you play the game, what's important to you, etc.
I would say the worst have to be:
1. Doctor Chapel - zero uses, including even for shuttles
2. Commander Dolim **tsk tsk** for base, voyage, only two skills, no collections, and pretty annoying build
3. Colonel Karr, Commander Uhurha, Captain Kurn - **tsk tsk** every which way (Kurn has ok SEC) but have very strong ship abilities. Karr is hard to build but in a collection.
4. Mirror Sisko, Defiant Commander Worf, Mirror Ezri Tigan all **tsk tsk** for base, voyage, only two skills, no collections, and pretty annoying builds.
5. KDF Gowron, Weyoun Clone 4 - they **tsk tsk** but at least 3 skills, and are Diplomat which is a hard collection to finish.
6. Tomalak - **tsk tsk** bigtime, but at least counts toward two collections
7. Lore, Lieutenant Arex Na Eth, Fencing Sulu, nothing noteworthy about them, no collections.
8. Commander Sela, Cardassian Kira, Tash, Dr Toby Russell, all not good, have seen some event uses for Sela/Kira and decent in some gauntlets depending on the traits, and each count toward one collection.