New Gauntlet Character - Who should it be?
Commander Sinclair
✭✭✭✭✭
in The Bridge
We have pondered, and discussed what we 'want', now let's view this from a purely Star Trek lore and try to make sense for what DB thinks as well. Best guess wins?
Gauntlet #1: Locutus – villain, but created as antithesis of beloved character.
Gauntlet #2: Guinan – well known character in ST lore, spanning generations, seemingly immortal and very wise.
Gauntlet #3: Caretaker – Single appearance in two parter episode, not a villain, but through his "benevolent" actions takes ships from other quadrants and strands them and their respective crews. 'He means well', protagonist.
Gauntlet #4: Armus – The absolute emergence of Evil, as was his subtitle "The Skin of Evil". Villain
Gauntlet #5: – ??
After Guinan, I wanted to see another Villain such as Trelane or Khan. I think Trelane was already introduced.
My original thoughts for next Gauntlet were along the lines of 'Q', but since he is themed so much in the rest of the game, it doesn't make sense to add him to Gauntlet. (Also since Judge Q runs the Gauntlet.)
So far, 2 Villains, and 2 non-Villains, and 3/4 are from TNG.
So...it comes down to this; Do we go Villain for the next one or not? Either way, should it be a recurring character or another one-off? I can think of a lot of possibilities, but most of them we already have as crew, and I am assuming DB will create a new one for this. This list could get extensive, but I am picking only maybe 2 possibilities per show to try and narrow it down. I also should think it would not be a Starfleet crew of any kind. I am also taking into account who DB may or may not have rights to. It has been said they can't get TOS Harry Mudd or Charlie X, both of which would have been great for Gauntlet IMO. This was a very difficult list to assemble BTW, as most of the proper characters are already in the game. (Maybe the same hard choices DB is having?)
possibilities for non-Villains:
TOS: Flint – immortal, protagonist
TNG: Kivas Fajo – Zibalian trader with no morals
DS9: Eris – Dominion infiltrator with telekinetic abilities
VOY: Captain Ransom – okay, exception to my own rule, desperate but murderer
ENT: "spectral temporal meddler" – can't find a name for him/her, antagonist
DISCO: Ba'ul – enslavers of the Kelpiens (Technically a Villain, but I found a better villain for that list)
possibilities for Villains:
TOS: Lord Garth, criminally insane, genetically manipulated by Antosians
TNG: ???
DS9: Jaro Essa – Bajoran Militia, extremest
VOY: ???
ENT: Valdore – The Romulan who had the drone ship attacking the quadrant
DISCO: Control Leland
Yes, there are a couple open spots I couldn't figure out, but that's okay, because this is hard enough without more choices.
My personal wish is to get a TOS character, and I think Lord Garth would be ideal from nearly every perspective.
Gauntlet #1: Locutus – villain, but created as antithesis of beloved character.
Gauntlet #2: Guinan – well known character in ST lore, spanning generations, seemingly immortal and very wise.
Gauntlet #3: Caretaker – Single appearance in two parter episode, not a villain, but through his "benevolent" actions takes ships from other quadrants and strands them and their respective crews. 'He means well', protagonist.
Gauntlet #4: Armus – The absolute emergence of Evil, as was his subtitle "The Skin of Evil". Villain
Gauntlet #5: – ??
After Guinan, I wanted to see another Villain such as Trelane or Khan. I think Trelane was already introduced.
My original thoughts for next Gauntlet were along the lines of 'Q', but since he is themed so much in the rest of the game, it doesn't make sense to add him to Gauntlet. (Also since Judge Q runs the Gauntlet.)
So far, 2 Villains, and 2 non-Villains, and 3/4 are from TNG.
So...it comes down to this; Do we go Villain for the next one or not? Either way, should it be a recurring character or another one-off? I can think of a lot of possibilities, but most of them we already have as crew, and I am assuming DB will create a new one for this. This list could get extensive, but I am picking only maybe 2 possibilities per show to try and narrow it down. I also should think it would not be a Starfleet crew of any kind. I am also taking into account who DB may or may not have rights to. It has been said they can't get TOS Harry Mudd or Charlie X, both of which would have been great for Gauntlet IMO. This was a very difficult list to assemble BTW, as most of the proper characters are already in the game. (Maybe the same hard choices DB is having?)
possibilities for non-Villains:
TOS: Flint – immortal, protagonist
TNG: Kivas Fajo – Zibalian trader with no morals
DS9: Eris – Dominion infiltrator with telekinetic abilities
VOY: Captain Ransom – okay, exception to my own rule, desperate but murderer
ENT: "spectral temporal meddler" – can't find a name for him/her, antagonist
DISCO: Ba'ul – enslavers of the Kelpiens (Technically a Villain, but I found a better villain for that list)
possibilities for Villains:
TOS: Lord Garth, criminally insane, genetically manipulated by Antosians
TNG: ???
DS9: Jaro Essa – Bajoran Militia, extremest
VOY: ???
ENT: Valdore – The Romulan who had the drone ship attacking the quadrant
DISCO: Control Leland
Yes, there are a couple open spots I couldn't figure out, but that's okay, because this is hard enough without more choices.
My personal wish is to get a TOS character, and I think Lord Garth would be ideal from nearly every perspective.
I want to become a Dilionaire...
0
Comments
Kevin Uxbridge and Control Leland could also be decent candidates.
Second Star to the Right - Join Today!
To @Commander Sinclair 's point, most of the major and worthy characters are already represented in the game. But while Honor Hall has shown a willingness to present special versions of main characters, the Gauntlet has so far shied away from that. Alas, it starts to mean characters who had lesser impact on screen.
Heck, I'm even going through the movies in my mind and other than "God" and Decker (the latter of which having obvious issues), I'm mostly drawing blanks.
What does God need with a starship?
100% This. It's name recognition that matters, not categorizing people into series and villain or not. Find a well known character not in the game and that's who it should be.
Ambassador Sarek from TOS/Movies
Harry Mudd if they ever got the rights straightened out
V'Ger
I didn’t know who the caretaker was until he showed up in Gauntlet. Kevin Uxbridge was in just as many episodes as Armus. And Armus only killed one person. Kevin wiped out an entire race
I'll go a bit further and suggest from the same arc Li Nalas. Downside of him might be that I'd think he'd be another Diplomacy-primary character like Guinan and Locutus.
You might not have known the name caretaker, but you probably remembered the alien who brought Voyager to the delta quadrant.
You might not have known the name armus, but you probably remember the oil slick that killed Tasha.
Kevin Uxbridge is just another alien of the week. There was nothing he really did in that was memorable outside of the episode.
Nope. Don’t know the guy, don’t know who brought him there, so yeah. Let’s keep going for like 20 more comments
Captain Level: 95
VIP Level: 12
Unique Crew Immortalized: 525
Collections Completed: Vulcan, Ferengi, Borg, Romulan, Cardassian, Uncommon, Rare, Veteran, Common, Engineered, Physician, Innovator, Inspiring, Diplomat, Jury Rigger, Gauntlet Legends
Proud member of Patterns of Force
Captain Level 99
Played since January 2017
TP: Do better!!!
I'm going to assume that if you don't know who the Caretaker is, you have never seen an episode of Voyager?
Also, could also go with Grey Hair Data (name subject to change
Or he has never seen the two part pilot that he is apparently from. Which I must have seen at some point when Voyager was show on tv but I also had to Google who this guy was. Which probably has to do with me not watching a lot of Voyager because I didn’t like the show, but I still know the main characters. Just not a guy who was only in two episodes.
I suspect that might fall into the same category. I feel like he's mentioned quite a bit, especially in the early seasons, but if you aren't familiar with the context you could easily miss the reference. But back to the premise of the character needing to have name recognition, I think Caretaker would easily fall into that category for 95% of players familiar with the IP.
I think you mean this.
I'd like to see Janice Lester show up someday too, but I think she'd fit best in a Kirk event.
Having just watched the Prophet Kira / Pah Wraith Jake episode from DS9, I'd be in favor of one of them as well. That was a cool scene. I half-expected the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man to show up as the evil vessel. (For those that have forgotten, which I would assume is 'everyone', I am currently watching the final seasons of DS9 for the first time, having stopped after season 3 when it was live.)
My vote was for this guy.
Future Guy from Enterprise.
Although I remember reading somewhere that it was really Capt. Archer from the future manipulating himself.
I think would make a killer gauntlet character.
We could also consider this guy as well.
God!