Which Legendary Would You Immortalize - Guinan or Kahless?

Irial

Suppose you have both Bartender Guinan and Kahless the Unforgettable at 1/5*. And since additional copies of each are no longer available, the only way to add more Stars to them is through Citations. Now further suppose you felt you could spare 200,000 Honor to Immortalize one of them - which one would you choose to make a 5/5*?

Jim Steele

Guinan 100% everytime (I have her immortal already) but MED and DIP is more useful than CMD etc...

Jim

Dirk Gunderson

If these were the only two left on my crew to immortalize, I might pick Kahless. I’ve been loaded on MED crew for a while now and she would not be better than Crell Moset or Cornwell, while Kahless would beat my Borg Queen for #1 in COM.

bowdy

I would immortalise Kahless. He's higher ranked for voyages than her, and is the highest ranked for voyages in his skill set, whereas guinan is 2nd in hers after Cornwell.

Jim Steele

bowdy wrote: »

I would immortalise Kahless. He's higher ranked for voyages than her, and is the highest ranked for voyages in his skill set, whereas guinan is 2nd in hers after Cornwell.

Fair point @bowdy - I'm not really missing him due to MirrorJeanLuc and Burnham both being immortal in my roster.

Jim

Capt. Chaos

I did Kahless already, Guinan is up next.

Banjo1012

I would go Guinan. There are more crew with the skills of Khaless than the skills of Guinan.

Marko Ramius

Irial wrote: »

Suppose you have both Bartender Guinan and Kahless the Unforgettable at 1/5*. And since additional copies of each are no longer available, the only way to add more Stars to them is through Citations. Now further suppose you felt you could spare 200,000 Honor to Immortalize one of them - which one would you choose to make a 5/5*?

If you do in fact plan on spending 200,000 honor to immortalize someone, I'd actually wait until you get Caretaker. His stats are a rarer combination than the others, and he's great for voyages.

Peachtree Rex

Marko Ramius wrote: »

Irial wrote: »

Suppose you have both Bartender Guinan and Kahless the Unforgettable at 1/5*. And since additional copies of each are no longer available, the only way to add more Stars to them is through Citations. Now further suppose you felt you could spare 200,000 Honor to Immortalize one of them - which one would you choose to make a 5/5*?

If you do in fact plan on spending 200,000 honor to immortalize someone, I'd actually wait until you get Caretaker. His stats are a rarer combination than the others, and he's great for voyages.

The problem with "wait for Caretaker" is that you should probably wait until Caretaker rotates out of the gauntlet. It's not exactly unlikely that you'll get additional copies of him over the next 3-6 months that he is the Gauntlet reward.

Irial

Marko Ramius wrote: »

If you do in fact plan on spending 200,000 honor to immortalize someone, I'd actually wait until you get Caretaker. His stats are a rarer combination than the others, and he's great for voyages.

Peachtree Rex wrote: »

The problem with "wait for Caretaker" is that you should probably wait until Caretaker rotates out of the gauntlet. It's not exactly unlikely that you'll get additional copies of him over the next 3-6 months that he is the Gauntlet reward.

Yes, I am very fortunate to already have The Caretaker at 2/5*, and with more good luck will acquire additional copies via The Gauntlet.

Thanks to All for your feedback!

Matt_Decker

As always, it depends on the rest of your crew and where your own strengths and weaknesses lie. In my case, I've got solid command and (thanks to Adm. Cornwell) good medical. What I lack is a really outstanding engineer. I haven't been fortunate enough to pick up a Caretaker yet.

I've also got 200k honor to burn, and am debating putting it into one of these 1/5 engineers:

• Assimilated La Forge
• Romulan Data
• Dress Uniform Scotty
• Cadet Sylvia Tilly
• Tempted Data
• Mirror Data

Data1001

Matt_Decker wrote: »

As always, it depends on the rest of your crew and where your own strengths and weaknesses lie. In my case, I've got solid command and (thanks to Adm. Cornwell) good medical. What I lack is a really outstanding engineer. I haven't been fortunate enough to pick up a Caretaker yet.

I've also got 200k honor to burn, and am debating putting it into one of these 1/5 engineers:

• Assimilated La Forge
• Romulan Data
• Dress Uniform Scotty
• Cadet Sylvia Tilly
• Tempted Data
• Mirror Data

Romulan Data kicks butt. So much so, that I have a 2nd copy of him (only 2/5 right now), but still occasionally put it to use. But he makes it on most of my Voyages, and many of my shuttles.

(CSF) Jesus Is Lord [••••]

Data1001 wrote: »

Matt_Decker wrote: »

As always, it depends on the rest of your crew and where your own strengths and weaknesses lie. In my case, I've got solid command and (thanks to Adm. Cornwell) good medical. What I lack is a really outstanding engineer. I haven't been fortunate enough to pick up a Caretaker yet.

I've also got 200k honor to burn, and am debating putting it into one of these 1/5 engineers:

• Assimilated La Forge
• Romulan Data
• Dress Uniform Scotty
• Cadet Sylvia Tilly
• Tempted Data
• Mirror Data

Romulan Data kicks butt. So much so, that I have a 2nd copy of him (only 2/5 right now), but still occasionally put it to use. But he makes it on most of my Voyages, and many of my shuttles.

Wow...i also have a ff/fe Romulan Data and a 2/5 second copy (which i have yet to fully equip), he is good indeed...and he used to be my best engineer and id debate whether to put him on my voyage or shuttles...But one day that all changed!!

BAM! I can reserve Romulan Data for my shuttles and send this Engineer on all my voyages...once the mega event is done of course.

Ironagedave

I can't afford to splurge on Khaless, so it's Guinan - i'm working on her now and hopefully by the end of today I will have her 3/5 and then I need to time how quickly I can get another 50k in honor. I know it's roughly a month but considering it's going to be tight to FF her before next mega event and have a citation spare for the next mega event legendary. It will be interesting how quickly I can accumulate the honor.