Do you think Moogie should have been a 5*?

Tcal

In the event rerun of Rule 125, DB has added Moogie as a 4* character. Would you be more interested in the event if she was a 5* character on par with Grand Nagus Zek? Chime in below!

Brunt, FCA

Absolutely Yes!

Yes but I'll mostly just be happy to get her.

Dralix

I'm of the odd opinion that a company can make their own business decisions and the customers can vote with their wallets.

Torias327

No. She is just fine as a 4*

I appreciate having the chance to get one of my most requested and desired characters without spending 50$ or devoting my entire weekend without sleep to placing 1200th place and feeling sad after.

Xoiiku

Absolutely Yes!

·§ë· Xoiiku wrote: »

That said, the 4* version would be acceptable, if and only if, there is a 5* version of Ishka being planned for a future event.

Tcal

Absolutely Yes!

Dralix wrote: »

I'm of the odd opinion that a company can make their own business decisions and the customers can vote with their wallets.

True, but that is not the only option to have your voice heard. You can vote with your wallet AND make your voice heard directly. These are not mutually exclusive.

Xoiiku

Absolutely Yes!

Tcal wrote: »

Dralix wrote: »

I'm of the odd opinion that a company can make their own business decisions and the customers can vote with their wallets.

True, but that is not the only option to have your voice heard. You can vote with your wallet AND make your voice heard directly. These are not mutually exclusive.

+10,000

Captain Paddy

No. She is just fine as a 4*

Less 5* Personnel is better

Althea Biermont

No. She is just fine as a 4*

If someone like Keiko only rates 1 star even though she was in a slew of episodes of two different Trek series, I think a 4* for Moogie is fine.

Capt. Chaos

Other/Indifferent (Comment below!)

Who the hell is Moogie?

Ivanstone

Well...now that you mention it...

I think there's enough space in game for a 4 and 5* Moogie.

The more important question is who gets the 5* version? Andrea Martin or Cecily Adams?

Yateball

No. She is just fine as a 4*

I really don't understand the "But Zek was a 5!" arguments.... OK cool, Ishka isn't Zek. Zek was long time Nagus.... if anything, him being a 5 and Ishka being a 4 makes perfect sense

Odo Marmarosa

No. She is just fine as a 4*

The adjective implies more versions are in the future.

Xoiiku

Absolutely Yes!

Yateball wrote: »

I really don't understand the "But Zek was a 5!" arguments.... OK cool, Ishka isn't Zek. Zek was long time Nagus.... if anything, him being a 5 and Ishka being a 4 makes perfect sense

Durring Ishka's story arc in DS9 it is revealed that at a certain point she had become the power behind the throne of the Grand Nagus, and every bit of Zek's equal. Or his better, considering she is more socially progressive and less caught in archaic and discriminatory traditions which have prevented roughly half of Ferengi culture from contributing toward it's advancement and profit.

Ivanstone wrote: »

I think there's enough space in game for a 4 and 5* Moogie.

Agreed.

Odo Marmarosa wrote: »

The adjective implies more versions are in the future.

I think this is likely and hopefully the case.

·§ë· Xoiiku wrote: »

·§ë· Xoiiku wrote: »

That said, the 4* version would be acceptable, if and only if, there is a 5* version of Ishka being planned for a future event.

Siblin

No. She is just fine as a 4*

When was the last time we had a 5* as existing crew? i'd say take it, else we'll always be fighting the endless inflation of crew slots

P-Rex

No. She is just fine as a 4*

I don't see why she should automatically be 5* just because zek is. Anyone with Captain Nog is going to be happy. I'd be happy enough to leave it at that.

Hungry Dog DDM

No. She is just fine as a 4*

If she was a 5* then I would never obtain her. 4* is just fine by me.

RennJaxo

I think we'll see more versions of her, and most likely a 5-star in the future. And we should totally have more versions of Keiko, including a 5-star Pah Wraith version.

Captain Durf

No. She is just fine as a 4*

I am down with her being a 4*. I don’t think we need to have reruns with two 5* characters.

On a side note, I personally despise the Ferengi centric episodes on DS9. They are the worst. Ugh.

Zetterbeard

No. She is just fine as a 4*

No. Not every brand new crew member has to be a legendary.

I'd honestly like to see more new 3* and 4* crew.

(HGH)Apollo

RennJaxo wrote: »

I think we'll see more versions of her, and most likely a 5-star in the future. And we should totally have more versions of Keiko, including a 5-star Pah Wraith version.

We need tng keiko and not ds9 keiko. On TNG she was thoughtful and kind, on DS9 the writers made her mean and unhappy. I hate how they changed her character into mainly just the one-dimensional foil of Miles.

[7TW] UnkieB

Ishka should be both a 4* now and another version a 5* later.

Dirk Gunderson

Well...now that you mention it...

I will be grumpy if we don’t get a 5* later but I suppose I’m okay with this for now.

Jhamel

Absolutely Yes!

I think she would have been worf a gold, however ... her title is "Proffittable" Ishka ... so there might be another Ishka variant in the future as 5*, who knows.

FutureImperfecta

There likely will be more .. we've gotten 2 Q's from 1 episode, she was in.. at least 5 that I can remember off the top of my head..

Don't worry, there will be more Ishkas then Archers Soon. Lol

Antasil

No. She is just fine as a 4*

She certainly has some status in the series, but no need to make her legendary. Also, this way more people can acquire an Ishka!

Thurthorad

No. She is just fine as a 4*

Dralix wrote: »

I'm of the odd opinion that a company can make their own business decisions and the customers can vote with their wallets.

That seems like a pretty stupid approach. Good businesses elicit customer preferences before bringing a product to market.

Businesses are also not just answerable to their customers. There are usually many stakeholders in any enterprise. In this case, as trivial as it may be I can think of at least 4, licence holder, shareholders, management and customers.

There may also be debt holders, or other legal relationships that constrain a company, including a healthy regulatory environment.

The idea that a business owner should be some sort of medieval prince doing what they please is thankfully a compete myth.

Dralix

Thurthorad wrote: »

That seems like a pretty stupid approach. Good businesses elicit customer preferences before bringing a product to market.

Businesses are also not just answerable to their customers. There are usually many stakeholders in any enterprise. In this case, as trivial as it may be I can think of at least 4, licence holder, shareholders, management and customers.

There may also be debt holders, or other legal relationships that constrain a company, including a healthy regulatory environment.

The idea that a business owner should be some sort of medieval prince doing what they please is thankfully a compete myth.

All of which has nothing to do with my point.

Thurthorad

No. She is just fine as a 4*

Dralix wrote: »

Thurthorad wrote: »

That seems like a pretty stupid approach. Good businesses elicit customer preferences before bringing a product to market.

Businesses are also not just answerable to their customers. There are usually many stakeholders in any enterprise. In this case, as trivial as it may be I can think of at least 4, licence holder, shareholders, management and customers.

There may also be debt holders, or other legal relationships that constrain a company, including a healthy regulatory environment.

The idea that a business owner should be some sort of medieval prince doing what they please is thankfully a compete myth.

All of which has nothing to do with my point.

What was your point then?

[BL] C6pilot

No. She is just fine as a 4*

I think 4* is more than enough for her. Most Ferengi episodes are simply too goofy to acknowledge. I don't have anything against Ferengi characters, just the writers. Too much childish comedy that got worse with time. I'm sure others like them just for that reason.

LeadHead

Other/Indifferent (Comment below!)

I am 0% concerned about this. I fully expect for another version of Moogie to come out at some point that would be a 5*.

There are specific versions of characters that need to be legendary. TWOK Spock, Captain Riker, (Best of Both Worlds) Commodore Matt Decker are examples. One version of Moogie being a 4, is not a wory.