Will that orange aura be present on the art in game? I think you guys have put out promotional stuff in the past that had that sort of thing not make it in the game.
I'm not very well versed with Discovery, is there a justification for Amanda's linguist trait? Seems very out of place from what I know of the character.
Between the trait and character variants, the pool of event crew for this event is fantastic. Not only a large number, but very balanced in terms of traits. Thank you!!
I'm not very well versed with Discovery, is there a justification for Amanda's linguist trait? Seems very out of place from what I know of the character.
For that matter, why does she have Vulcan trait. She was not Vulcan, not 1/2 Vulcan, TOS Amandas do not have Vulcan trait. I don't really care one way or the other, just a hmmm
Founding ADM - PoF family of fleets (POF, POF2 & POF3) - Dear TP: Non sequitur. Your facts are uncoordinated.
I'm not very well versed with Discovery, is there a justification for Amanda's linguist trait? Seems very out of place from what I know of the character.
For that matter, why does she have Vulcan trait. She was not Vulcan, not 1/2 Vulcan, TOS Amandas do not have Vulcan trait. I don't really care one way or the other, just a hmmm
This issue has, of course, been hashed, rehashed, and then hashed at least one more time by the community. I will attempt to be politer than others have been in the past.
I'd actually take the opposite view: old lady Grayson and Awaiting Amanda should have the Vulcan trait. The comparison here is to Odo and Rom who have the Bajoran trait. Amanda is much more a citizen of Vulcan, rather than Earth. In fact, her character has never been shown to be anything else.
I'm not very well versed with Discovery, is there a justification for Amanda's linguist trait? Seems very out of place from what I know of the character.
For that matter, why does she have Vulcan trait. She was not Vulcan, not 1/2 Vulcan, TOS Amandas do not have Vulcan trait. I don't really care one way or the other, just a hmmm
Several crew who are culturally associated with a species have the trait, Miranda Jones for one. Yes, they're very inconsistent with this, but they also added the Vulcan trait to Graduation Burnham back in November, presumably while Graduation Amanda was in production.
I'm in favor of adding the trait for societal reasons for characters who are clearly part of the culture such as by marriage or having lived in a place for an extended period. Just wish they'd be more consistent overall.
I'm not very well versed with Discovery, is there a justification for Amanda's linguist trait? Seems very out of place from what I know of the character.
For that matter, why does she have Vulcan trait. She was not Vulcan, not 1/2 Vulcan, TOS Amandas do not have Vulcan trait. I don't really care one way or the other, just a hmmm
This is issue has, of course, been hashed, rehashed, and then hashed at least one more time, by the community. I will attempt to be politer than others have been in the past.
I'd actually take the opposite view: old lady Grayson and Awaiting Amanda should have the Vulcan trait. The comparison here is to Odo and Rom who have the Bajoran trait. Amanda is much more a citizen of Vulcan, rather than Earth. In fact, her character has never been shown to be anything else.
Works for me, like I said, don't care, just curious
Founding ADM - PoF family of fleets (POF, POF2 & POF3) - Dear TP: Non sequitur. Your facts are uncoordinated.
Similarly to other versions, Graduation Amanda Grayson should not have the Vulcan trait and this will be corrected next week as well.
Let me rephrase that!
Other versions of Amanda Grayson do not have the Vulcan trait.
The fact that Graduation Amanda Grayson has the Vulcan trait has been reported by QA but the fix will not go live before next week.
double posting for extra visibility
We had a quick discussion about this and we've decided to leave the Vulcan trait for Graduation Amanda Grayson. The trait will not be added to her other variations,
I appreciate the feedback regarding how the vulcan trait is being used for other characters and will forward it.
Graduation Amanda Grayson will be the recurrent threshold reward throughout this mega arc, allowing you to gain four copies in total. She is also part of three collections! (‘Great Compassion’, ‘Live Long and Prosper’, and ‘Healthy Discourse').
That should read - Unlike other versions Amanda Grayson correctly has the Vulcan trait and this will be added to the other versions along with all Michael Burnhams (in addition to Graduation Burnham who was recently corrected to provide the correct precedent for this crew)
Graduation Amanda Grayson will be the recurrent threshold reward throughout this mega arc, allowing you to gain four copies in total. She is also part of three collections! (‘Great Compassion’, ‘Live Long and Prosper’, and ‘Healthy Discourse').
And you are now removing a collection reducing her value. What other trait will you give her to keep her in 3 collections?
The fact that Graduation Amanda Grayson has the Vulcan trait has been reported by QA but the fix will not go live before next week.
Did it occur to anyone at WRG that nerfing the centerpiece card for the upcoming mega, post-announcement, is more expensive than leaving it be? You even have precedent in Graduation Michael Burnham as an excuse to not make a change now.
Graduation Amanda Grayson will be the recurrent threshold reward throughout this mega arc, allowing you to gain four copies in total. She is also part of three collections! (‘Great Compassion’, ‘Live Long and Prosper’, and ‘Healthy Discourse').
And you are now removing a collection reducing her value. What other trait will you give her to keep her in 3 collections?
She will now have Timelines’ Original because she doesn’t have the Vulcan trait like the character in the shows do so she will be an original.
But Amanda Grayson, who lived on Vulcan for over 50 years, married a Vulcan, engaged in Vulcan tradition doesn't get it applied to any of her variants? The mistake is not in removing it from this one, it should have been on all Amanda Grayson variants already.
We had a quick discussion about this and we've decided to leave the Vulcan trait for Graduation Amanda Grayson. The trait will not be added to her other variations,
I appreciate the feedback regarding how the vulcan trait is being used for other characters and will forward it.
We had a quick discussion about this and we've decided to leave the Vulcan trait for Graduation Amanda Grayson. The trait will not be added to her other variations,
I appreciate the feedback regarding how the vulcan trait is being used for other characters and will forward it.
Thx Shan. I just hope that the feedback doesn’t end up with a large scale removal of Vulcan trait from those that have it on that list.
So, Graduation Amanda is Dip Cmd Sec. On Timelines Talks, it was predicted that she would be Dip primary. Good job there.
And Walt also speculated that she wouldn't be CDS around an hour and 28 minutes. And then the idea was sort-of mocked. If you didn't watch it, I'd recommend you do so now to see Auto's explanation of how she could have Sec. It is now in my head-canon, and will probably make you never be able to watch that scene the same again.
So, Graduation Amanda is Dip Cmd Sec. On Timelines Talks, it was predicted that she would be Dip primary. Good job there.
And Walt also speculated that she wouldn't be CDS around an hour and 28 minutes. And then the idea was sort-of mocked. If you didn't watch it, I'd recommend you do so now to see Auto's explanation of how she could have Sec. It is now in my head-canon, and will probably make you never be able to watch that scene the same again.
I was really hoping the Med would have been kept in from existing Amanda builds... feels like every new gold crew given, even if strong, are various orders of Com/Dip/Sec.
Comments
In general, great art, decent till great(Angel)stats of new crew, so far.
Please keep it up! 👍🏻👏🏻
But…
While we investigate!
Will that orange aura be present on the art in game? I think you guys have put out promotional stuff in the past that had that sort of thing not make it in the game.
Pretty nice art regardless 👍
Here's what the in-game art looks like.
And it will be fixed next week!
For that matter, why does she have Vulcan trait. She was not Vulcan, not 1/2 Vulcan, TOS Amandas do not have Vulcan trait. I don't really care one way or the other, just a hmmm
This issue has, of course, been hashed, rehashed, and then hashed at least one more time by the community. I will attempt to be politer than others have been in the past.
I'd actually take the opposite view: old lady Grayson and Awaiting Amanda should have the Vulcan trait. The comparison here is to Odo and Rom who have the Bajoran trait. Amanda is much more a citizen of Vulcan, rather than Earth. In fact, her character has never been shown to be anything else.
Several crew who are culturally associated with a species have the trait, Miranda Jones for one. Yes, they're very inconsistent with this, but they also added the Vulcan trait to Graduation Burnham back in November, presumably while Graduation Amanda was in production.
I'm in favor of adding the trait for societal reasons for characters who are clearly part of the culture such as by marriage or having lived in a place for an extended period. Just wish they'd be more consistent overall.
Works for me, like I said, don't care, just curious
Let me rephrase that!
Other versions of Amanda Grayson do not have the Vulcan trait.
The fact that Graduation Amanda Grayson has the Vulcan trait has been reported by QA but the fix will not go live before next week.
double posting for extra visibility
We had a quick discussion about this and we've decided to leave the Vulcan trait for Graduation Amanda Grayson. The trait will not be added to her other variations,
I appreciate the feedback regarding how the vulcan trait is being used for other characters and will forward it.
Always quick to remove traits. Always drags feet at adding traits.
Um, what? You literally advertised her to us as having this trait as if you knew it was a selling point:
And you are now removing a collection reducing her value. What other trait will you give her to keep her in 3 collections?
Did it occur to anyone at WRG that nerfing the centerpiece card for the upcoming mega, post-announcement, is more expensive than leaving it be? You even have precedent in Graduation Michael Burnham as an excuse to not make a change now.
She will now have Timelines’ Original because she doesn’t have the Vulcan trait like the character in the shows do so she will be an original.
Vulcan - Miranda Jones
Vulcan - Mintakan Troi
Vulcan - Graduation Michael Burnham
Vulcan - Mintakan Riker
Cardassian - Mirror Regent Worf
Cardassian - Investigator Odo
Cardassian and Klingon - Mirror Intendant Kira
Klingon - Kal'Hyah Sisko
Klingon - Kal'Hyah Bashir
Klingon - Kal'Hyah O'Brien
Klingon - Determined Paris
Klingon - Jodmos
Klingon - Klingon Janeway
Klingon - Klingon Bride Jadzia
Klingon - Klingon Quark
Klingon - Blood Oath Jadzia Dax
Klingon - Klingon Dukat
Romulan - Romulan Picard
Romulan - Romulan Data
Romulan - Rakal Troi
Borg - The One, Lore
But Amanda Grayson, who lived on Vulcan for over 50 years, married a Vulcan, engaged in Vulcan tradition doesn't get it applied to any of her variants? The mistake is not in removing it from this one, it should have been on all Amanda Grayson variants already.
I appreciate the feedback regarding how the vulcan trait is being used for other characters and will forward it.
Angel Burnham 5* voyage rank 29 according to BigBook.
Thx Shan. I just hope that the feedback doesn’t end up with a large scale removal of Vulcan trait from those that have it on that list.
And Walt also speculated that she wouldn't be CDS around an hour and 28 minutes. And then the idea was sort-of mocked. If you didn't watch it, I'd recommend you do so now to see Auto's explanation of how she could have Sec. It is now in my head-canon, and will probably make you never be able to watch that scene the same again.
As all the crew are on the wrong ships, perhaps we should be getting T'Ana.
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/VideoExamples/StarTrekLowerDecksS1E08Veritas
I was really hoping the Med would have been kept in from existing Amanda builds... feels like every new gold crew given, even if strong, are various orders of Com/Dip/Sec.