Options
Okay, Vic Fontaine question.....
DScottHewitt
✭✭✭✭✭
in The Bridge
Pretend I only saw most episodes of Deep Space once, when they originally aired years ago. I thought that Vic Fontaine was a lounge singer from like the 1960s or 1970s that they saw perform in the Holo-Suites. Yet, in the Mirror Universe, Vic Fontaine was a live person from the 24th Century? In the regular Universe, was he like a 24th Century lounge singer, who sang classic lounge songs or something?
Scott
Scott
Why was Vicki not expelled from Greendale after she literally stabbed Pierce in the face with a pencil?!?!?
0
Comments
Proud Former Officer of The Gluten Empire
Retired 12-14-20. So long, and thanks for all the cat pics!
There's speculation that Bashirs friend who wrote the Vic program made Vic look like himself (Bashirs friend) or some other 'real' person and that is who the Mirror Vic is a counterpart to.
So, basically we are left wondering? In our universe, Hologram. In the Mirror, maybe a real person?
Scott
Thanx!!!!!
Scott
Sounds like another day in the mirror universe. Or the Q episodes. Or anytime they mention time, or quantum. Meh, pretty much the entire ST world, with odd lack of constant discontinuity in the soap opera called DS9.
Wow, having watched DS9 more than 30 times through I have to strongly disagree with the 'constant discontinuity' comment.
There were some, yes, but constant would put it in the realm of... Enterprise.
Invitation code: https://discord.gg/8Du7ZtJ
You missed the double negative, "odd lack of constant discontinuity". It was a back handed way of saying DS9 did much better than most ST, though it still had some flaws at times.
It definitely did that job, from the sounds of it.
I consider it maybe one of those Easter Eggs we never really know why it was there things.....
Scott
Invitation code: https://discord.gg/8Du7ZtJ
Rishon Uxbridge was a human, then ... some sort of recreation of a human.
Why couldn't prime Vic Fontaine have been a human, then a hologram?
Why would the EMH look like a real person? Same answer? Because it was modeled after one?
Except we *know* Vic wasn't, it was an invention of Bashir's friend.
I don't understand your train of thought. Juliana Tainer was a human and an android was then made to approximate her. That is not the same thing as saying 'in one universe this person is a real person and in another it's a holodeck character'. With this logic anything mirror would be acceptable to you. We could have mirror Quark where he isn't a Ferengi he's a Vulcan, after all Juliana Tainer...
Because the mirror universe isn't logically consistent. It's an excuse to let the actors play the characters differently.
Yes I agree.
Clearly.
No. It's the same as saying "Vic Fontaine was a human and a hologram was then made to approximate him."
Im done. Your sarcasm shows you can't have an adult conversation.
We don't know that he wasn't based on a "real" person just like the EMH was. The EMH was an invention as well (of Dr. Zimmerman who used his own likeness). Perhaps they should have called him Mirror Felix (assuming Bashir's friend Felix used his own likeness for a model).
Do we know Vic wasn't? I'm not so sure. We never saw Felix in-universe to know what his appearance is. There's certainly precedent for holographic programmers using their own likeness for their creations (inventor's conceit). As far as I'm aware it's not stated by Julian either way. Quark and Rom have probably never met Felix and would only associate that face with the hologram, hence their confusion on meeting him in the mirror universe. We see him responding to the name Fontaine (Mirror Julian calls him it I think) but again inventor conceit could be in play. We don't know Felix's surname. He could be Felix Fontaine. Who knows, perhaps he modelled Vic on an ancestor he researched heavily and that's why the holoprogram is so good?
A lot of ifs and maybes, but the point is that I don't think there's enough evidence to make a categorical statement for either side of the argument. All we can do is hypothesise based on the available evidence. We know Felix (no stated surname) created the program for Julian, we don't have details on how he went about it though and what he took as inspiration. And we have a mirror universe rebel who answers to the name Fontaine and looks a lot like the hologram. Doesn't mean it is the hologram, that's just an assumption by Quark and Rom.
So.. maybe mirror Vic is using a Mobile Emitter.
Exactly. If you want to go deeper, how do these alternate versions of primary universe crew even exist? Somehow, over hundreds of years and many generations, the precise genetic pairings needed to result in their birth were identical despite wildly varying conditions between the prime and mirror universes. Somehow, nobody's ancestor died early from warfare, famine, disease or accident; no ancestor failed to meet their spouse due to different circumstances; and the right sperm fertilized the right egg every time. The further away you go from the point of divergence, the more unlikely any of that is to happen.
The entire concept of a mirror universe with highly divergent societies and history but genetically identical people is not really credible, but we're willing to accept it for the sake of story. Compared to that absurdity, is the idea that in the mirror universe the fates aligned to create a flesh-and-blood human with an appearance identical to a holographic person in the prime universe really that far-fetched?
This should have been the end of the thread. @Merwinian nailed it.