Ahdar Ru'afo not giving bonus is event broken

Hesham

Event is broken ?????

Hesham

[DB:LOL] eXo | Kurrostanza

Already reported:

https://forum.disruptorbeam.com/stt/discussion/10807/ruafo-bugged-for-skirmishes#latest

https://forum.disruptorbeam.com/stt/discussion/10805/ru-afo-not-giving-appropriate-rewards#latest

[QH] Captain Ziggy

Ru'afo is bugged, the other event crew are fine

Ace_Rimmer

Darn it. Took me about 2 rounds to realise.

Capt. Chaos

I'll just leave this here.

SunshineRiker

Thanks for reporting. We're investigating!

SunshineRiker

After investigating event bonuses for Adhar Ru'afo and other crew, we found that all the bonuses are working as intended.

Please note, that in phase 1 of this event, Ru'afo only has matching bonus crew traits in the first three of the five skirmish battles. If used in those first three skirmish battles, he receives the high bonus which is a larger bonus than crew receiving low bonus and non-event crew receiving the base bonus for having an applicable trait. Ru'afo, and other crew who do not have the bonus crew traits, will not receive any bonus in the fourth and fifth skirmish battles.

Example: Battle 1/5 with the Veteran and Brutal traits (Ru'afo has Brutal trait).


Example: Battle 4/5 with the Starfleet and Physician traits (Ru'afo does not have either of these traits).

RNGeverything

Of course the event is broken, DB set it up.

McCaptainface

But hes

DealWithItJazzRiker wrote: »

After investigating event bonuses for Adhar Ru'afo and other crew, we found that all the bonuses are working as intended.

Please note, that in phase 1 of this event, Ru'afo only has matching bonus crew traits in the first three of the five skirmish battles. If used in those first three skirmish battles, he receives the high bonus which is a larger bonus than crew receiving low bonus and non-event crew receiving the base bonus for having an applicable trait. Ru'afo, and other crew who do not have the bonus crew traits, will not receive any bonus in the fourth and fifth skirmish battles.

Example: Battle 1/5 with the Veteran and Brutal traits (Ru'afo has Brutal trait).


Example: Battle 4/5 with the Starfleet and Physician traits (Ru'afo does not have either of these traits).

But he is event crew? Whats the point of having event crew if they dont provide abonus

guest_794681753632768

Seriously? he is event crew, do you guys not read your own posts? he should give max regardless of traits, just like the last skirmish
event.

Ego Draconis

Ok... regarding these bonuses, Ru'afo has as bonus the traits, stacked with whatever percentage event crew has, or exclusively the traits?
Not sure whether my question is clear, and I am hopeful it doesn't get buried under following posts.

Capt. Chaos

DealWithItJazzRiker wrote: »

After investigating event bonuses for Adhar Ru'afo and other crew, we found that all the bonuses are working as intended.

Please note, that in phase 1 of this event, Ru'afo only has matching bonus crew traits in the first three of the five skirmish battles. If used in those first three skirmish battles, he receives the high bonus which is a larger bonus than crew receiving low bonus and non-event crew receiving the base bonus for having an applicable trait. Ru'afo, and other crew who do not have the bonus crew traits, will not receive any bonus in the fourth and fifth skirmish battles.

Then that works differently than past skirmish events.

guest_794681753632768

Wake me up when they figure out, that he is actually event crew ;p and get their heads out of their you know where;)

SSR Barkley

@DealWithItJazzRiker that's not how main event crew work in skirmishes. they give the full bonus for every battle, regardless of traits.

CaptainUnderpants

Well that makes sense. Can't do QA right if you don't know what you're actually testing for. Explains so much now.

Ego Draconis

Capt. Chaos wrote: »

Then that works differently than past skirmish events.

Which begs the question: was BR Bashir's skirmish event not working as intended?
If yes, then why were not these changes communicated to the players? If not, idem?
Also, why change a rule that exists since the Borg event?

Amphistaff

SSR Barkley wrote: »

@DealWithItJazzRiker that's not how main event crew work in skirmishes. they give the full bonus for every battle, regardless of traits.

This. If you're going to change how bonus crew work in skirmished fine, but you HAVE to tell us BEFORE the event starts, not hours later. Yet another bait and switch...

Guest

The in-game event rules make no mention of needing to match traits. It says that Ru'afo will provide a bonus. Seems pretty cut and dried to me .....

Drone_one

Amphistaff wrote: »

SSR Barkley wrote: »

@DealWithItJazzRiker that's not how main event crew work in skirmishes. they give the full bonus for every battle, regardless of traits.

This. If you're going to change how bonus crew work in skirmished fine, but you HAVE to tell us BEFORE the event starts, not hours later. Yet another bait and switch...

And if so, why are Yelgrun and First Goran'Agaar providing bonus?

Mirror Cartman

DealWithItJazzRiker wrote: »

Example: Battle 4/5 with the Starfleet and Physician traits (Ru'afo does not have either of these traits).

Thankyou for the clarification @DealWithItJazzRiker , now could you please explain why Weyoun Clone 4 gives a bonus in your screenshot, when he is neither Starfleet or a Physician.
As I said in the other thread, First Goran'Ager also gets a bonus in battle 4/5, and he does not have matching traits.

JohnofCharleston (AA)

DealWithItJazzRiker wrote: »

After investigating event bonuses for Adhar Ru'afo and other crew, we found that all the bonuses are working as intended.

...

Example: Battle 4/5 with the Starfleet and Physician traits (Ru'afo does not have either of these traits).

This is still bugged. Another way to prove that:

Goran'Agar does not have Starfleet or Physician traits, yet he does provide the full 100% bonus, because he is event crew. To get the bonus you must have event crew OR match the traits, not both. Ru'afo was announced in advance as full event crew and should get exactly the same bonus Goran'Agar does.

[S14] Elynduil

Couldn't even run a bath...

t<G>e Roonis

DealWithItJazzRiker wrote: »

After investigating event bonuses for Adhar Ru'afo and other crew, we found that all the bonuses are working as intended.

Please note, that in phase 1 of this event, Ru'afo only has matching bonus crew traits in the first three of the five skirmish battles. If used in those first three skirmish battles, he receives the high bonus which is a larger bonus than crew receiving low bonus and non-event crew receiving the base bonus for having an applicable trait. Ru'afo, and other crew who do not have the bonus crew traits, will not receive any bonus in the fourth and fifth skirmish battles.

Example: Battle 1/5 with the Veteran and Brutal traits (Ru'afo has Brutal trait).


Example: Battle 4/5 with the Starfleet and Physician traits (Ru'afo does not have either of these traits).

This is completely counter to the mechanics of Skirmish events.

Trait match provides increased healing and hull. Event crew provide bonus VP.

"In addition, various crew members can give bonuses to hull and round-to-round healing based on their traits."
https://www.disruptorbeam.com/blog/2018/05/22/stt-skirmishes-a-new-event-type-coming-to-star-trek-timelines

It also has not worked like this in either of the two events that occurred so far, and others have cited examples from this event that contradict what you have stated.


This DB post is so wrong it's insulting.

Yateball

... again they just don't have any idea what they're doing... jeez

Travis S McClain

A behind-the-scenes look at DB:

Iknamur_

@DealWithItJazzRiker thank you (and your team) for having no clue how the game works. Dismissed, crewman.

<TGE> Donut

You know, I'd be upset with how poorly understood this intern is handling things, but this is par for the course.

Still, THIS IS THE EVENT RECURRING GOLD

guest_794681753632768

So are they still investigating? or do they not bother to look back to see what happened after they "think" they solved the issue. My patience wears thin, actually it wore thin a few months back, now its just par for the DB course.

[AR-UNI] General Abre

It is well known that traits affect other crew, but event crew should always be with bonus, in other words, I beleive Shan said once prior to the first Skirmish event: "Developers told me event crew will have the best trait match..." or something similar. Does the rest remember about this?

{DD} Smelly

Wow. Just... wow. DB's complete and utter incompetence on display for the whole world to see. Just amazing.